Warning: a guy at the Tacoma star party told me my M42 shots were "overcooked" and it stung because he was right
I've been stacking Orion Nebula frames from my backyard in Tacoma for about 3 months and I was pretty proud of this one edit with the core blown out and the dust lanes cranked until they looked like a painting. Then this older guy at the monthly star party glanced at my laptop and said "that's a nice picture of your processing, not the nebula" and walked off. My first reaction was that he was just being a grump, but I sat with it for a few days and pulled my raw subs back up and realized I'd been clipping the trapezium cluster completely white and pushing saturation to hide noise. So I started over with a much softer stretch, kept the core detail visible, and stopped chasing that neon look. Now I'm stuck wondering where the line is, because the other side of this is that half the photos I see online are so flat and gray that they look like they were shot through a dirty window. On one hand, we're recording what's actually up there and the data should lead; on the other, it's my telescope and my backyard and a little punch makes people actually stop and look at the screen. I keep going back and forth on which camp I belong to now. Where do you all land on this, do you edit for the photons or for the eyeballs?